Suno's V5: Technically Impressive, But Still Lacking Soul
AI Music
Suno
Artificial Intelligence
Music Generation
Vocals
Copyright
Music Technology
8
Mimicry, Not Mastery
Media Hype
7/10
Real Impact
8/10
What is the Viqus Verdict?
We evaluate each news story based on its real impact versus its media hype to offer a clear and objective perspective.
AI Analysis:
While the technical advancements are impressive, the fundamental lack of ‘soul’ in the AI’s output suggests a gap in true creative understanding, indicating a manageable challenge rather than a looming existential threat to music.
Article Summary
Suno’s latest AI music generator, model v5, offers a noticeable upgrade over its predecessor, v4.5+, with improvements in audio quality, more intricate song structures, and a better ability to handle complex musical arrangements. The model excels at replicating technical aspects of music production, such as cleaner mixes, clearer separation of instruments, and the incorporation of sophisticated harmonic layers. However, despite these advancements, the core problem persists: the music lacks soul. The vocals, in particular, are too perfect, exhibiting an unnerving smoothness and precision that undermines their believability. While the model accurately understands and mimics certain musical elements—like reverb, harmonies, and even attempts at effects—it fails to replicate the intentional imperfections, subtle nuances, and emotional weight characteristic of a human performance. Product manager Henry Phipps highlighted this issue, noting that the models don’t yet fully grasp the impact of specific effects or recording techniques. Despite the company’s claims about “emotionally rich” vocals, the generated vocals consistently sound sterile and generic, resembling the performances of artists like Imagine Dragons or Mumford & Sons, regardless of the prompts given. The model’s inability to simulate the emotional rawness of a real human performance—the crack in a voice during a crucial moment, a slight off-key note conveying desperation—remains a critical limitation.Key Points
- Suno v5 demonstrates significant technical improvements in audio quality and musical complexity compared to v4.5+.
- Despite the advancements, the generated vocals remain unnervingly perfect and lack the emotional depth and nuance of human performances.
- The model’s primary limitation lies in its inability to replicate the imperfections and emotional weight inherent in a real human vocal performance.